# Payroll and accounting software together or integrated?

> Compare built-in payroll, a connected payroll provider and journal imports by posting, corrections, funding and reconciliation.

- **Source:** https://www.runproper.com/resources/systems/payroll-built-in-or-integrated
- **Publisher:** Proper Technologies Inc.
- **Format:** System guide · Cash & Tally
- **Published:** 2026-11-17
- **Reading time:** 3 min

**Short answer.** Both setups can work. Choose based on who will run payroll, the countries and pay situations the setup must support, and how reliably each pay run, correction and payment can be traced into the books. A shared login tells you little about how the payroll and accounting records connect.

## What are the three common setups?

| Setup | What to ask the vendor to show |
| --- | --- |
| Payroll built into the accounting product | Who calculates and submits pay, what the accounting team can view, and how a corrected run changes the ledger |
| A separate payroll provider connected to accounting | How earnings, deductions and employer costs map to accounts or departments, and how a failed sync is retried |
| A supported payroll journal export and import | Who reviews the export, how a duplicate import is detected, and what evidence ties the imported journal back to the pay run |

For each setup, confirm geography, currencies, entities, pay schedules and which team owns the work. If project or department labour reporting matters, ask to see the actual allocation in the posted journal.

## What is the best demo for payroll-to-accounting integration?

Use a sample payroll run with two departments, employer costs and one deduction. Ask the vendor to show the approved run, funding or settlement evidence, the posted journal and who can view each record. Then correct an approved timesheet after the original run has been posted. Ask where the original is retained, what correction posts, and how the team confirms that only the intended adjustment is recorded.

For example, an illustrative $750 gross-pay correction may also affect deductions, employer costs and net pay. Ask to see the revised amounts and the reviewer’s trail from payroll to the journal and the bank. Use test data supplied for the demo.

## Is payroll funding the same as a payroll journal?

No. Funding answers how much cash must be available and when. The journal explains how payroll costs and related liabilities are recorded. A team can approve payroll, fund the run and post the journal at different points. Ask for statuses that let a reviewer tell those steps apart.

The [payroll handoff guide](https://www.runproper.com/resources/payroll/payroll-to-cash-and-accounting-handoffs) maps the evidence each team needs. The [Canadian payroll software comparison](https://www.runproper.com/resources/payroll/buyers-guide) offers implementation questions for teams evaluating a Canadian setup.

## Keep evaluating

-   [See how payroll funding and supplier payments share a cash plan](https://www.runproper.com/resources/systems/supplier-payments-around-payroll)
-   [Compare accounting software that includes AP, AR, payroll and the ledger](https://www.runproper.com/resources/systems/accounting-software-ap-ar-payroll)
-   [Ask Proper about your payroll and accounting setup](https://www.runproper.com/book)
